Captain's Lookout

Maryland, New York, United States 12116

  1.  Photos
  2.  Map
Captain's Lookout
Captain's Lookout is a beautiful location on Goodyear Lake
Spacious Living Room
Living Room
Kitchen with Stainless Steel Appliances
Wet Bar with Dinette
Dining Room
Wet Bar
Bedroom #1 with a king bed
Lower level living area/game room adjacent to bedrooms #1 and #5
Lower living area with foosball table
Lower living area with summer kitchen
Lower level laundry area and summer kitchen
Bedroom #2 with king size bed
Bedroom #3
Bedroom #3 with large flat screen smart Roku TV
Bedroom #4 wth Cathedral Ceiling and Ceiling Fan
Bedroom #4 - large flat screen smart Roku TV
Lower level bedroom #5 with two twin beds
Elegantly Tiled Bathroom
Contemporary Tiled Bathroom
Lake View from the Upper Deck
Back Deck Patio overlooking the Lake
Living Room with 55 (or larger) smart flat screen Roku TV with cable
Views of the lake from the balcony
Lake views!
Beautiful sweeping lake views from the upper deck
The lower level deck is an awesome place to enjoy morning coffee or cocktails and the sunset
Upper level laundry
Lower level laundry
  • Description

    • 12.6 miles to Cooperstown All-Star Village
    • 10.0 miles to Cooperstown Baseball World
    • 10.1 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park
    • 15.3 miles to Cooperstown

    NEW! Scroll down to take a 3D tour of this location, see the amenities, available weeks, property details and more!


    • Accommodates:8
    • Bedrooms:4
    • Bathrooms:5


    • Amenity Availability 24-hour Check-in
    • Amenity Availability Air Conditioning
    • Amenity Availability Balcony
    • Amenity Availability Cable TV
    • Amenity Availability Carbon Monoxide Detector
    • Amenity Availability Coffee Maker
    • Amenity Availability Deck / Patio / Balcony
    • Amenity Availability Dishes & Utensils
    • Amenity Availability Dishwasher
    • Amenity Availability DVD Player
    • Amenity Availability Fireplace
    • Amenity Availability Foosball
    • Amenity Availability Hair Dryer
    • Amenity Availability Heating
    • Amenity Availability Internet
    • Amenity Availability Iron & Board
    • Amenity Availability Kayak / Canoe
    • Amenity Availability Kid Friendly
    • Amenity Availability Kitchen
    • Amenity Availability Lakefront
    • Amenity Availability Linens Provided
    • Amenity Availability Living Room
    • Amenity Availability Microwave
    • Amenity Availability No Smoking
    • Amenity Availability Outdoor Grill
    • Amenity Availability Oven
    • Amenity Availability Parking Included
    • Amenity Availability Refrigerator
    • Amenity Availability Smoke Detector
    • Amenity Availability Stove
    • Amenity Availability Toaster
    • Amenity Availability Towels Provided
    • Amenity Availability TV
    • Amenity Availability Washer/Dryer
    • Amenity Availability Waterfront
    • Amenity Availability Wireless Internet
    • Amenity Availability Coffee Maker Combo - Pot or K-cup
    • Amenity Availability Crock Pot
    • Amenity Availability Flat Screen TV's
    • Amenity Availability Kayaks
    • Amenity Availability Lake access
    • Amenity Availability Outdoor Fire Pit
    • Amenity Availability Patio Area

    Rates and Availability

    Weeknight Weekend Night Weekly Monthly Min Stay
    Weekly Rental Rate
    06/05/2020 - 07/22/2021
    $500 / night$600 / night$3600 / weekN/A7
    Weekly Rental Rate - Event
    07/23/2021 - 07/29/2021
    $650 / night$750 / night$4600 / weekN/A7
    Weekly Rental Rate
    07/30/2021 - 07/21/2022
    $500 / night$600 / night$3600 / weekN/A7

    Specific Rate Details

    From June through August, we only rent weekly, with check in/out on Fridays.

    Unless otherwise noted, Standard Amenities for all rentals Include:

    - Bed linens, blankets, pillows
    - Bath towels
    - Fully equipped kitchen with microwave, coffee pot, toaster and utensils for cooking and serving .

    • Available
    • Property Not Available Unavailable
    • Past

    Perched above Goodyear Lake, Captain's Lookout has an awesome view of the lake from a series of decks overlooking the water, and there is room for grilling and dining on the top deck. This waterfront home has everything you need for an enjoyable vacation! Some of the features you will enjoy include a wet bar with quartz countertop in the main living area, heated floors in all of the bathrooms, laundry facilities on each level, and a summer kitchen on the lower level adjacent to the game room with foosball table. There are 2 kayaks for guests to use at the waterfront and they can easily be launched off the seawall.

    This 2,125 square foot waterfront home is nestled into the hillside, with the main living area and two bedrooms on the top floor - street level. Both street level bedrooms have queen size beds and their own private bathrooms. There are two more bedrooms on the lower level, both with king size beds, and private full bathrooms. There is a fifth full bathroom with whirlpool tub off the hallway on the main floor. There are 7 flat screen TVs - a large, 55" TV in the living room and 32" or larger TVs in each bedroom all connected to Cable TV.

    A well manicured yard in front of the home is large enough for playing a game of catch. For your comfort and convenience, this vacation home also features central air-conditioning, high speed wireless internet (Wi-Fi), and a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher and refrigerator with automatic ice maker.

    Centrally located, this spacious rental home is located:

    - No smoking
    - No pets
    - No team parties or large gatherings

    Add a Review
    • Great Family House

      Reviewed by Jeffrey N from PA on July 23, 2017 for their trip during July 14, 2017

      Beautiful view of the lake, great fishing, plenty of bathrooms, plenty of space, 2 kayaks, great back decks. Great family house! My only complaint is the kitchen could use some sharper knives. But I would definitely go back there and I would highly recommend to a friend.

    • Captain's Lookout has a Spectacular View!

      Reviewed by Suzanne H from CO on June 11, 2017 for their trip during June 02, 2017

      We loved our stay at the Captain's Lookout. The view is spectacular and the home is spacious. The ride into Cooperstown is easy and we loved staying away from the crowds. Thank you for the great accommodations.

    • Review for Captain's Lookout

      Reviewed by Dana DeFilippis from PA on August 20, 2016 for their trip during August 12, 2016

      Captain's Lookout had everything we needed. Great views of the lake and the ability to use the kayaks. Plus was having a separate bathroom for each bedroom. Large enough for us.

    • Review for Captain's Lookout

      Reviewed by Brian Doherty from Hatfield PA on August 13, 2016

      spacious, clean, beautiful views, plenty of amenities